How do we want to manage additions/removals to the stdlib?

With regards to PEP 387. Might we provide a specific discussion thread for users to comment in for each deprecation warning introduced?

I have noticed a very nonchalant attitude about removal of stdlib packages lately in Discussions. As was pointed out, most users don’t read the “What’s New” section of each release. I would go so far as to say most users don’t understand the open source development process Python goes through. I would also say that most don’t understand why things get deprecated.

Many of them would probably jump at the opportunity to give feedback on their usage and why they don’t want something removed, but I would imagine few of them know where to begin to give that feedback.

These same users (or their organization) may also be in a position to direct funding towards CPython maintenance. If the Python Software Foundation made it more straightforward for users to provide feedback and made it easy for them to provide funding (some kind of issue bounty system?) then end users could avoid potentially expensive efforts within their organization to migrate way from deprecated functionality.

1 Like