Thanks for your feedback, I appreciate the candor. However, my question is not ignorant of the use cases and the potential benefits a no-gil version to those use cases would have.
I am merely observing, from my own background, that the “GIL issues” are often raised due to considering a program and data design that are ameanable to shared-all free threading concurrency model, whereas Python (or rather CPython) effectively prefers shared-nothing concurrency. Incidentally, the latter has been known easier to reason about, to be less prone to failures, and in many cases also to be easier to scale.
I propose that this can be seen as a benefit, not a burden and I am asking if the risks inherent in a change of this dimension is warranted, including giving up on a fundamental benefit.